Integral methodology for value assessment of the 20th century architectural heritage in Bosnia and Herzegovina
Integralna metodologija vrednovanja arhitektonskog nasleđa 20. veka u Bosni i Hercegovini
Apstrakt
The legacy of the 20th century architecture in B&H is unrecognized as cultural heritage which results in great loses of important architectural work. An integral methodology was created with the intention to make the process of 20th century architectural heritage identification and value assessment in B&H systematic and context related. On one side, it is based on the theoretical knowledge that is rooted in charters, documents, and declarations of international and regional background with a stress on the authenticity and integrity of different criteria. While on the other hand, it is founded on the belief that analyses of architectural heritage have an equal representative potential and expertise visibility through graphical and descriptive form. Integral methodology was applied and demonstrated on the case study, the Crni vrh urban villa in Sarajevo, B&H. The results of the research are two folded: the first points out that the international set of criteria for the value assessment i...s complete only when specificities of the regional context are added; the second one shows that the graphical and descriptive part of value analyses and assessment are equally important and valuable and therefore inherently necessary in the process of creating conservation recommendations for the 20th century architectural heritage.
Nasleđe arhitekture 20. veka u BiH je neprepoznato kao kulturno nasleđe što rezultira velikim
gubicima važnih arhitektonskih dela. Integralna metodologija je formirana sa namerom da se proces
identifikacije i procene vrednosti graditeljskog nasleđa 20. veka u BiH učini sistematičnim i
kontekstualnim. S jedne strane, integralna metodologija se zasniva na teorijskom znanju koje je
ukorenjeno u poveljama, dokumentima i deklaracijama međunarodnog i regionalnog porekla s
naglaskom na autentičnost i integritet različitih kriterija. Dok se sa druge strane, zasniva na
uvjerenju da analiza graditeljskog nasleđa ima jednak reprezentativni potencijal i stručnu vidljivost
i kroz grafičku i deskriptivnu formu. Integralna metodologija je primijenjena i demonstrirana kroz
studiju slučaja urbane vile Crni vrh u Sarajevu, BiH. Rezultati istraživanja su dvojaki: prvi ističe da
je međunarodni set kriterijuma za procenu vrednosti potpun samo kada se dodaju specifičnosti
regionalnog konteksta; dr...ugi pokazuje da su grafički i deskriptivni deo analize i procene vrednosti
podjednako važni i vredni, a samim tim i inherentno neophodni u procesu kreiranja konzervatorskih
preporuka za arhitektonsko nasleđe 20. veka.
Ključne reči:
20th century architecture / integral methodology / value criteria / heritage identification / value assessment / urban villa / Bosnia and Herzegovina / arhitektura 20. veka / integralna metodologija / kriterijumi vrednosti / identifikacija nasleđa / procena vrednosti / urbana vila / Bosna i HercegovinaIzvor:
Facta universitatis - series: Architecture and Civil Engineering, 2023, 21, 1, 169-193Izdavač:
- Niš : University of Niš
DOI: 10.2298/FUACE230405011K
Cobiss ID: 98807559
ISSN: 0354-4605; 2406-0860 eISSN
[ Google Scholar ]Institucija/grupa
Arhitektonski fakultetTY - JOUR AU - Kahrović Handžić, Lejla AU - Nikezić, Ana PY - 2023 UR - https://raf.arh.bg.ac.rs/handle/123456789/2312 AB - The legacy of the 20th century architecture in B&H is unrecognized as cultural heritage which results in great loses of important architectural work. An integral methodology was created with the intention to make the process of 20th century architectural heritage identification and value assessment in B&H systematic and context related. On one side, it is based on the theoretical knowledge that is rooted in charters, documents, and declarations of international and regional background with a stress on the authenticity and integrity of different criteria. While on the other hand, it is founded on the belief that analyses of architectural heritage have an equal representative potential and expertise visibility through graphical and descriptive form. Integral methodology was applied and demonstrated on the case study, the Crni vrh urban villa in Sarajevo, B&H. The results of the research are two folded: the first points out that the international set of criteria for the value assessment is complete only when specificities of the regional context are added; the second one shows that the graphical and descriptive part of value analyses and assessment are equally important and valuable and therefore inherently necessary in the process of creating conservation recommendations for the 20th century architectural heritage. AB - Nasleđe arhitekture 20. veka u BiH je neprepoznato kao kulturno nasleđe što rezultira velikim gubicima važnih arhitektonskih dela. Integralna metodologija je formirana sa namerom da se proces identifikacije i procene vrednosti graditeljskog nasleđa 20. veka u BiH učini sistematičnim i kontekstualnim. S jedne strane, integralna metodologija se zasniva na teorijskom znanju koje je ukorenjeno u poveljama, dokumentima i deklaracijama međunarodnog i regionalnog porekla s naglaskom na autentičnost i integritet različitih kriterija. Dok se sa druge strane, zasniva na uvjerenju da analiza graditeljskog nasleđa ima jednak reprezentativni potencijal i stručnu vidljivost i kroz grafičku i deskriptivnu formu. Integralna metodologija je primijenjena i demonstrirana kroz studiju slučaja urbane vile Crni vrh u Sarajevu, BiH. Rezultati istraživanja su dvojaki: prvi ističe da je međunarodni set kriterijuma za procenu vrednosti potpun samo kada se dodaju specifičnosti regionalnog konteksta; drugi pokazuje da su grafički i deskriptivni deo analize i procene vrednosti podjednako važni i vredni, a samim tim i inherentno neophodni u procesu kreiranja konzervatorskih preporuka za arhitektonsko nasleđe 20. veka. PB - Niš : University of Niš T2 - Facta universitatis - series: Architecture and Civil Engineering T1 - Integral methodology for value assessment of the 20th century architectural heritage in Bosnia and Herzegovina T1 - Integralna metodologija vrednovanja arhitektonskog nasleđa 20. veka u Bosni i Hercegovini VL - 21 IS - 1 SP - 169 EP - 193 DO - 10.2298/FUACE230405011K ER -
@article{ author = "Kahrović Handžić, Lejla and Nikezić, Ana", year = "2023", abstract = "The legacy of the 20th century architecture in B&H is unrecognized as cultural heritage which results in great loses of important architectural work. An integral methodology was created with the intention to make the process of 20th century architectural heritage identification and value assessment in B&H systematic and context related. On one side, it is based on the theoretical knowledge that is rooted in charters, documents, and declarations of international and regional background with a stress on the authenticity and integrity of different criteria. While on the other hand, it is founded on the belief that analyses of architectural heritage have an equal representative potential and expertise visibility through graphical and descriptive form. Integral methodology was applied and demonstrated on the case study, the Crni vrh urban villa in Sarajevo, B&H. The results of the research are two folded: the first points out that the international set of criteria for the value assessment is complete only when specificities of the regional context are added; the second one shows that the graphical and descriptive part of value analyses and assessment are equally important and valuable and therefore inherently necessary in the process of creating conservation recommendations for the 20th century architectural heritage., Nasleđe arhitekture 20. veka u BiH je neprepoznato kao kulturno nasleđe što rezultira velikim gubicima važnih arhitektonskih dela. Integralna metodologija je formirana sa namerom da se proces identifikacije i procene vrednosti graditeljskog nasleđa 20. veka u BiH učini sistematičnim i kontekstualnim. S jedne strane, integralna metodologija se zasniva na teorijskom znanju koje je ukorenjeno u poveljama, dokumentima i deklaracijama međunarodnog i regionalnog porekla s naglaskom na autentičnost i integritet različitih kriterija. Dok se sa druge strane, zasniva na uvjerenju da analiza graditeljskog nasleđa ima jednak reprezentativni potencijal i stručnu vidljivost i kroz grafičku i deskriptivnu formu. Integralna metodologija je primijenjena i demonstrirana kroz studiju slučaja urbane vile Crni vrh u Sarajevu, BiH. Rezultati istraživanja su dvojaki: prvi ističe da je međunarodni set kriterijuma za procenu vrednosti potpun samo kada se dodaju specifičnosti regionalnog konteksta; drugi pokazuje da su grafički i deskriptivni deo analize i procene vrednosti podjednako važni i vredni, a samim tim i inherentno neophodni u procesu kreiranja konzervatorskih preporuka za arhitektonsko nasleđe 20. veka.", publisher = "Niš : University of Niš", journal = "Facta universitatis - series: Architecture and Civil Engineering", title = "Integral methodology for value assessment of the 20th century architectural heritage in Bosnia and Herzegovina, Integralna metodologija vrednovanja arhitektonskog nasleđa 20. veka u Bosni i Hercegovini", volume = "21", number = "1", pages = "169-193", doi = "10.2298/FUACE230405011K" }
Kahrović Handžić, L.,& Nikezić, A.. (2023). Integral methodology for value assessment of the 20th century architectural heritage in Bosnia and Herzegovina. in Facta universitatis - series: Architecture and Civil Engineering Niš : University of Niš., 21(1), 169-193. https://doi.org/10.2298/FUACE230405011K
Kahrović Handžić L, Nikezić A. Integral methodology for value assessment of the 20th century architectural heritage in Bosnia and Herzegovina. in Facta universitatis - series: Architecture and Civil Engineering. 2023;21(1):169-193. doi:10.2298/FUACE230405011K .
Kahrović Handžić, Lejla, Nikezić, Ana, "Integral methodology for value assessment of the 20th century architectural heritage in Bosnia and Herzegovina" in Facta universitatis - series: Architecture and Civil Engineering, 21, no. 1 (2023):169-193, https://doi.org/10.2298/FUACE230405011K . .